Arpaio to judge: Fat chance of apology

By Nick R. Martin | November 19th, 2009 | 4:00 am | 40 Comments »

Joe Arpaio talks to the media
Joe Arpaio | Photo by Evan Wyloge

Sheriff Joe Arpaio said Wednesday it will be a cold day in Maricopa County before one of his officers apologizes for taking an attorney’s confidential files.

He was responding to Maricopa County Superior Court Judge Gary Donahoe, who on Tuesday ordered a county detention officer to apologize for a bizarre incident in which he was caught on a courtroom security video sneaking a confidential document from a defense attorney’s file.

Donahoe ordered officer Adam Stoddard to hold a press conference before Dec. 1 to apologize to the attorney or else face jail time.

“Superior Court judges do not order my officers to hold press conferences,” Arpaio said in a news release. “I decide who holds press conferences and when they are held.”

Read the full story…

Judge orders officer to apologize or face jail for taking attorney's file

By Nick R. Martin | November 18th, 2009 | 8:44 am | 39 Comments »


Detention officer Adam Stoddard is shown on courtroom videotape taking a document from a defense attorney’s file.

If he doesn’t make a grand public apology to a defense attorney soon, a Maricopa County detention officer could find himself inside a jail cell rather than tending them.

A Maricopa County judge on Tuesday ordered detention officer Adam Stoddard to hold a news conference and publicly apologize for swiping a document from a defense attorney’s file behind her back last month in an incident caught on courtroom videotape. If the Maricopa County Sheriff’s officer refuses or the defense attorney decides the apology is not “sufficient,” Judge Gary Donahoe’s ruling said he would throw Stoddard in jail.

Donahoe’s ruling held Stoddard in contempt for the Oct. 19 incident in which he could be seen on a courtroom security video sneaking up behind attorney Joanne Cuccia in the middle of a hearing and taking a document from her file.

Read the full story…

Pulitzer winner leaving Arizona Guardian for Afghanistan

By Nick R. Martin | November 13th, 2009 | 8:53 am | No Comments »


Paul Giblin

Yes, you read that headline right. Pulitzer Prize-winner Paul Giblin is leaving the Arizona Guardian less than a year after he helped found it to go to Afghanistan in a civilian role with the U.S. Army.

His departure from the political news website has been one of the worst kept secrets in Arizona journalism circles in recent weeks, but Giblin had consistently declined to confirm his new position until it was certain.

Late yesterday, he made it official. In a note on the Guardian’s website, Publisher Bob Grossfeld said Giblin would be spending a year stationed in Afghanistan, though he didn’t say exactly what the prize-winning journalist would be doing there. Grossfeld also said Giblin may occasionally pen a letter from overseas for the Guardian site.

“I hope you’ll join with us in not only wishing Paul the best of luck,” Grossfeld wrote, “but also including him in your prayers every now and then.”

Read the full story…

Judge says he's walking 'a line' with officer who took attorney's file

By Nick R. Martin | November 11th, 2009 | 11:58 am | 13 Comments »


Judge Gary Donahoe

Maricopa County Judge Gary Donahoe looked out on a courtroom divided cleanly in half on Tuesday, all the way back through the gallery. On one side was a packed batch of local defense attorneys. On the other, a battery of sheriff’s deputies, each donning a brown uniform and badge.

Donahoe scanned the courtroom and shrugged. “There is a line here that I have to balance,” he said. Then he asked the two sides what he should do.

Donahoe has been overseeing a rather bizarre case in recent weeks surrounding what a sheriff’s employee did to a defense attorney on Oct. 19 in full view of courtroom security cameras.

The employee, detention officer Adam Stoddard, was caught on tape sneaking behind the back of defense attorney Joanne Cuccia and taking a document from her files while she was speaking in court that day.

Read the full story…

Freedom strikes again; Publisher, editor out at Ahwatukee paper

By Nick R. Martin | November 9th, 2009 | 12:43 pm | 5 Comments »

It seems no one at Freedom Communications in Arizona is safe from the chopping block this month.

Publisher Renie Scibona and Managing Editor Brian Johnson have been shown the door at the Ahwatukee Foothills News, one of several newspapers in the Phoenix area owned by the California media chain.

Freedom Vice President Julie Moreno sent a memo to staffers last week announcing the layoffs and wishing the two “the best of luck in their future endeavors.”

Read the full story…

Ahwatukee newspaper, a survivor, asks for a little help to get by

By Nick R. Martin | November 8th, 2009 | 3:38 am | 2 Comments »


Renie Scibona

Len Gutman over at the Valley PR Blog made a pretty amazing discovery when he opened up his copy of the Ahwatukee Foothills News on Saturday.

The little community newspaper that survived recent cutbacks by its parent company, Freedom Communications, had printed a full-page ad in the day’s edition essentially begging for reader donations.

“We too have done more with less!” publisher Renie Scibona wrote in the letter to readers, noting how the newspaper has added videos and photo slide shows to its website. “Your loyalty and voluntary contribution will help us continue to bring you one of Arizona’s best community newspapers for years to come.”

The letter was also posted online along with a link at the bottom, urging readers to give whatever they can. In exchange, the paper will give contributors a free classified ad. (A free classified ad, you say?)

Read the full story…

Officer tells which 'keywords' made him take attorney's document

By Nick R. Martin | November 7th, 2009 | 12:23 am | 24 Comments »


Detention officer Adam Stoddard is captured on courtroom videotape taking a document from a defense attorney’s file behind her back.

Maricopa County detention officer Adam Stoddard was back in court Thursday to explain why he sneaked a document out of a defense attorney’s file behind her back a few weeks ago, stunning attorneys nationwide after the whole thing was caught on a courtroom videotape.

JJ Hensley of the Arizona Republic was at the hearing and wrote Friday that Stoddard continued to defend his actions as a legal search because he believed a crime was perhaps taking place. Stoddard was also finally allowed to tell the court which “keywords” he saw on the document that sent him into action. Hensley wrote:

“Going to,” “steal” and “money.”

Those four words, grouped in the same sentence, prompted a Maricopa County sheriff’s detention officer to remove documents from a defense attorney’s
file last month, according to court testimony Thursday.

Officer Adam Stoddard testified that a handful of factors contributed to his decision to position himself behind the defendant, Antonio Solis Lozano, during Lozano’s Oct. 19 sentencing hearing. And while Stoddard was there, his eyes “glazed over” a document with the four words that caught his attention.

Read the full story…

'Freedom Bonus Central' now live

By Nick R. Martin | November 6th, 2009 | 4:41 pm | 3 Comments »

Since Heat City broke the news Thursday that executives with Freedom Communications have been pocketing millions in bonuses while slashing jobs and pay for their employees, a lot of you have been asking for the raw data to see who got what and when.

The bonuses have received so much national attention that I’ve created a special page called “Freedom Bonus Central” that lays out information.

There, you can find an embedded Google spreadsheet with all the data, as well as the bankruptcy documents that detailed the bonuses originally. Also, I understand that more Freedom publishers and executives may have received further bonuses as the company sped toward bankruptcy. I’m trying to confirm this and will add the information if and when I do.

Read the full story…

En route to bankruptcy, Freedom execs pocketed $2.6M in bonuses

By Nick R. Martin | November 5th, 2009 | 2:33 am | 53 Comments »


Julie Moreno


Jonathan Segal

When Freedom Communications executives Jonathan Segal and Julie Moreno announced Monday the company would be shutting down the East Valley Tribune newspaper at the end of the year, they told staffers it was due, in part, to the bad economic state of the news industry. Freedom was under bankruptcy protection, the Tribune was losing money and the company just didn’t have the wherewithal to keep the Mesa newspaper afloat.

What Segal and Moreno did not say, however, was that behind the scenes of their company’s decline, the two of them continued to do very well financially thanks to hefty bonuses given out to executives this year by Freedom Communications.

In fact, documents filed Oct. 24 in federal court in Delaware show that bonus payments as high as $775,000 were widespread within Freedom’s top ranks as the media chain barreled toward bankruptcy. In all, 19 of the company’s top officers pocketed a combined $2.6 million in the first eight months of 2009 alone.

All the while, those who took the extra cash continued to lay off workers or slash pay at most of Freedom’s 100-plus news outlets nationwide. As consolation, the executives told employees their decisions were difficult and not made lightly.

Read the full story…

A little paper that often beat the big one soon will be silenced

By Nick R. Martin | November 2nd, 2009 | 10:15 pm | 2 Comments »

Brad Armstrong worked as a photographer at the East Valley Tribune for 20 years, and he was more than just a little bit upset when the newspaper laid him off in January along with about 140 other people.

So Armstrong did not expect to feel the way he did when word came down this morning that the paper was shutting down by the end of the year. The Tribune had hurt him, so why should he feel badly about its demise?

His own reaction surprised him more than the closure.

Read the full story…

« Newer stories | Older stories »